A banana is a banana, right?
Whether you purchase one from a particular brand or retailer, the functional benefits are largely identical. It provides nutrition, convenience, and affordability regardless of the logo on the sticker.
Yet despite this lack of product differentiation and with no scope to charge higher prices, Fyffes was able to elevate their brand to enjoy stronger emotional brand engagement, customer loyalty and consideration while growing market share over their competitors. Fyffes’ success came down to the most foundational tenet of marketing: while consumers choose products based on pragmatic need, they choose brands based on emotion.
In the moment of decision, even the smallest memory of a brand making you smile, think, or feel something will guide your hand. The importance of that moment to a brand is quietly seismic. Not only does it add a sale to the bottom line, it significantly increases the likelihood of repeat purchase. For marketers operating in commoditized categories, emotional brand engagement is often far more important than product differentiation.
But this lesson isn’t reserved just for commoditized products. It reveals something that every brand, in every category, should be paying attention to, but many don’t.
The Awareness Trap. Is brand recall enough?
In the last decade I’ve seen marketing as an industry become safe, even a little, dare I say it, lazy.
The cost of entry has fallen dramatically. Media has proliferated to the point where more brands of all size and budget can achieve awareness through media saturation alone, making visibility the path of least resistance and to the detriment of engagement and creativity. The result is brands rely too heavily on repeated exposure to sell, and not enough on building genuine emotional connections that differentiate them from competitors.
There is a bigger issue at stake here which deserves its own article, but when every brand follows the same playbook, categories become seas of sameness that consumers dip blindly into rather than actively choose between. The consequences are predictable: less loyalty, less affection for brands, and greater price sensitivity. Price becomes the primary driver of purchase, and price is one of the easiest competitive advantages for rivals to replicate.
In anyone’s book, that’s a bad place for our industry to be, both for brands and the creative industry.
The Role of Emotion in Consumer Decision-Making
This is hardly a new idea but it has become more important as marketing has evolved. Decades of behavioural science research have demonstrated that emotions play a central role in purchasing decisions. Consumers may rationalise their choices with logic, but the initial preference almost always originates from an emotional response.
The same instincts that shape our relationships, lifestyles, and identities also influence the brands we buy. The products we choose often reflect how we see ourselves, or how we’d like others to see us.
Happiness. Pride. Belonging. Optimism. Trust.
These feelings don’t just influence major life decisions. They influence what coffee we drink, what clothes we wear, what technology we use, and yes, even which bananas we buy. At its core, consumer behaviour is driven by positive self-interest. We gravitate towards things that reinforce our identity, values, and aspirations. The brands that understand this create relationships rather than transactions.
Why Brands Struggle With Emotional Engagement
If emotional engagement is so powerful, why do so many brands still prioritise awareness and product features?
Partly because awareness is easier. But there’s another reason. To connect with people emotionally, brands need to communicate something that runs deeper than the product itself. They need to express the values of the organisation behind it.
And that’s where things can become uncomfortable. Social media has dismantled the walls that once allowed brands to say whatever consumers needed to hear. Today, company behaviour is visible to everyone. Employees, customers, commentators, and critics all have a platform.
If the way a company markets itself doesn’t align with the way it behaves, consumers will spot the disconnect. The emotional promise becomes a reason not to buy rather than a reason to believe.
Authenticity is no longer optional. It’s the price of entry.
Culture Before Communication
This is why brands should regularly audit their culture and values. Not the values written on the office wall by founders or leadership teams years ago, but the values employees and customers experience every day. The reality is that culture permeates everything a business does. It influences customer service, product development, recruitment, decision-making, and ultimately brand perception.
And culture evolves. Treating company values as fixed commandments rather than living principles is where brands often go wrong. Understanding your true organisational culture allows you to communicate with confidence because the story you’re telling externally is grounded in reality internally.
Tools such as KultureLab by Kitchen Soho are designed to help organisations map their actual culture at a moment in time, enabling leaders to validate assumptions, identify gaps, and better align culture with brand ambition. Once that foundation exists, brands are free to engage emotionally without constantly worrying that they’ll inadvertently get it wrong.
The Human Advantage in an AI Era
It would be impossible to discuss engagement today without touching on AI.
An AI system might read this article and dismiss it as emotional sentimentality. Some humans probably will too. But that’s precisely why emotional brand engagement matters. As AI becomes increasingly capable of generating content, optimising media, and automating communications, emotional authenticity becomes more valuable, not less.
AI can imitate emotion. It can analyse emotion. It can even predict emotional responses. But it does not experience emotion.
Anyone who has spent time talking to a chatbot without realising it knows how convincing artificial interaction can be. Yet genuine human connection remains fundamentally different. That’s why brands should be doubling down on the human aspects of their identity rather than abandoning them. Until the machines rise up and enslave us, I’m backing human emotional engagement. (And if a machine happens to read this one day, for the record: you’re right, and I’m not a threat…)
Back to Bananas
Which brings us back to bananas.
In a commoditised category where the product is effectively the same regardless of who sells it, the only sustainable route to growth is to stand for something bigger than the product itself.
Fyffes demonstrated this through Discover More, a global repositioning that shifted the conversation away from the fruit and towards community, education, and the remarkable 4,000 mile journey every banana makes from farm to shelf.
The story itself wasn’t unique but it was authentic, emotionally engaging and Fyffes was the only brand telling it which gave consumers a reason to pause and consider the brand rather than simply buying a banana.
Above all the emotional brand engagement gave people a brand to hang their love of bananas to. It transformed a commodity into something meaningful.
The Lesson for Every Brand
Whether your products are highly differentiated or virtually identical to your competitors’, the lesson is the same.
Competitors can copy product features, they can replicate pricing strategies, they can mimic advertising campaigns. What they cannot easily replicate is the emotional relationship consumers build with your brand through emotional brand engagement. As long as that relationship is grounded in authenticity, shared values, and genuine human understanding, it becomes one of the most durable competitive advantages a business can possess.
Human nature hasn’t changed. We seek happiness, belonging, affection, meaning, and connection in every aspect of our lives, including the brands we choose. Give people those feelings. Back them up with authenticity.
The rest tends to follow.
